So I've used a few of Dan's really nice ultra thin "Humidor" humbuckers, and they really solve the height problem so I don't have to notch into the neck (or I onlky have to notch a tiny bit).

But I'd like to try a few other options for both variety and economy.  I have inquired at Gitty about the heights of their pickups but never got a response.  I'll ask again over there, but I thought I'd like to ask here too.

So what is a decent pickup that is affordable and is not tool tall?  Typical mag pups get up to 1/2" tall or more, which seems too much to notch into the neck.  Obviously the taller the pickup, the deeper the notch required in the neck, and I still want to keep the action nice and low.

Thanx in advance,

/Mark

You need to be a member of Cigar Box Nation to add comments!

Join Cigar Box Nation

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • You could always add a piece to thicken the neck in the box. That way the neck strength won't be compromised when notching for pickups.

    That Lowrider Gold Foil pup would be nice. It sounds great.

  • Flat pup, they sound awesome have a word with Dan if you are in the US

    I found a way to put a pickup off to the side using a spring under it with a floating magnet and a small buzzer coil

    but the sound is unique...works like a piezo but electric. 

    alternatively you can use long nails through the neck and a coils on the back of the neck with strong ni

    magnets.

  • Have you checked out " Cross Road Blues" pick ups? I have one and it is very thin and sounds great. They are really cool looking too but they are $60.00 

  • The other option is to raise the action a bit so the neck-notch isn't very deep.  If you skip the springs, and have the pickup pulled all the way up, a thin notch and  brace is all you should need.  I use fretboard scraps for heel stock.  a 1/4" piece of good hardwood would be plenty to reinforce a notched neck.

  • Coupla things,as Ron says/under 1/2 inch is getting down to speciality areas,particularly under 1/4.Imake a lot of my own pups now,more as a challenge than a search for 'the' pup,thinner without specialised equipment relates to higher cost per unit,i've made copies of Elmars' and it's a bit more fiddly work than a standard type pup/the quality of Dan and Elmar's pups[essentially identical]warrants there pricing.An ultra thin humbucking pup ready to throw into your git is worth a couple of extra bucks i feel,plus it keeps the money circulating in the community

  • I suggest the surface mounted Lowrider Vintage Gold Foil Standard Pickups they are claiming 5/16" height. The two I used on my new three string are more like 3/8" height and sound great! Please see website https://reverb.com/item/259424-lowrider-vintage-gold-foil-standard-...  Not real cheap but they are the thinnest I have found.

    GEDC5429.JPG

  • Nope, around 1/2" is pretty standard for mag pup height. Most people notch the neck, add wings to support the adjustment screws, and often add another piece of wood beneath the neck to strengthen that area. That's how Dan did his before the Thinbucker, but I can't seem to find the pic.
  • I just bought an Elmar flatpup for the electric Appalachian Mountain Dulcimer I'm building- totally awesome- check them out! http://www.cigarboxnation.com/profile/ElmarZeilhofer
    • The Elmar's seem the same as the Humidors.But he has a discount thru August, so maybe I should grab one.

This reply was deleted.