So I lucked into a reallllllly cool looking solid wood box that I believe is all mahogany, it’s a Camacho Connecticut 6X60 20 count box, with a very cool looking black face with the scorpion logo. It’s just crying for a Humbucker and walnut fretboard. The only issue is the top of the box is thick, on the order of 3/8 solid mahog under that beautiful wrapper. The sides and bottom are mahog as well. The bottom is 1/8, and the sides about 3/8 also. My thinking is use the router to chew away the underside of the lid, leaving it full thickness at the periphery, where it closes onto the box, but thinning out the soundboard so it’ll play in acoustic mode also. Any thoughts on the ideal thickness I should make the top? I can preserve the outward appearance by removing the lid from the hinges and routings tge underside, but as it is, the top is deader than a picnic table. 

Views: 163


Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I've got 2 the same I'm going to flip them round build with the 1/8 bottom being now the top job sorted to keep it simple , there's no rules in this game . Have fun .

I thought of that, but that black lid with the scorpion in the middle would be so cool looking, lol. 

I just don’t want to destroy the darn thing, and wonder if routing it out but leaving the edge thick will let the top ring? 

The way these boxes are stored,  then  released from captivity , alot of them are dried out ,, and a router may be  a bit violent for them . one lil snag and the top may get torn apart . 

I'd  just pop the humbucker in it and call it an" electric" ,...... and if it still sounds  loud enough as an acoustic , that's a bonus .

When weighing looks and multi  function , sometimes ya cant get the best of both worlds .

but call it electric , and its perfect ;-)


Yep that's a good point Pick after my last outing with a router was a train wreck I should of waited till had my carpal tunnel done ... :-(

Hi, I have mentioned this before, thickness is not a real good guide to producing a top, thats if you are looking for a louder more tonefull guitar.

When I'm prepping a top and back for that matter, I look for flexibility. To this end many a luthier will graduate the thickness to be thinner around the outside edge. Of course stiffer tops can be thinned more than flimsy overflxible top. Then braces added to control movement and add stability.

Thats in the guitar world, but we are dealing with box's, but I use the same theories in my build of a CBG.

When I want the best I can get from both worlds, I build the best acoustic sounding top, but mount the magnetic pickup so it goes through the top without touching it.


All good thoughts. When I say router, that’s the short version of a Dremel with a router base using a 1/8” four flute end mill, so it’s not too likely to shake the world apart. Point taken that flexible is a good thing. I think I’m gonna give it a go and work toward around 1/8 inch with the border retained at full thickness. Worst case scenario it ends up a dedicated electric. Thanks folks. 

Well, it turns out that big 3/8 inch thick lid isn’t wood after all. So I routed away about half the thickness, down to 3/16 instead of 1/8, a little leary of going too thin with the cardboard. I used the black border inside the lid as a handy guide to , leave a full rim where the lid contacts the box at the original thickness. Did I mention it’s not wood, but that dense cardboard like a paper covered cigar box, only massively thick? That stuff produces the absolutely nastiest dust imaginable when routed with a four flute endmill at about 2/3 of full speed with a Dremel in a router base, but I got it done, and simply holding the lid on the box and giving it a “knock test”, it sounds a helluva lot better than it did.

Hi, I think that's what is called MDF here, man made fibre. Yep it's killer stuff, as in its not good for you. It will give out a fair  sound though. 


Hi, I think that's what is called MDF here, man made fibre. Yep it's killer stuff, as in its not good for you. It will give out a fair sound though.

Since I play through an amp most of the time (because I like loud) and since when I want to play quietly (like when I'm in a hotel room) I want to play very quietly... I've come to the conclusion that, for me, thickness doesn't matter. Makes my life a lot easier.  :D

But kudos to you guys that go for and achieve good acoustic tone and volume.

I hear you. I’m in an apartment with some very nice neighbors downstairs that go to bed early and get up early, so volume is an issue. But during the day nobody else in the building but me.  So on the electric front, I’m about to do a pair of guitars, one fretted, one not, using the three string DeltaBuckers. Eventually I’ll probably  go for a 10w tube amp. I told my son, if I only wanted to play electric, I’d skip the box entirely and use a stubby laminated canoe paddle as the whole darn thing. But I do enjoy acoustic guitar, so I’m trying to make that happen.  


The Essential Pages

New to Cigar Box Nation?How to Play Cigar Box GuitarsFree Plans & How to Build Cigar Box GuitarsCigar Box Guitar Building BasicsCigar Box Guitar Parts Store

Site Sponsor

Recommended Links & Resources


R.L. Burnside

Started by Mike Seymore in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by Shane Speal 4 hours ago. 4 Replies

fret cutting jig

Started by Alan Dillard in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Alan Dillard 5 hours ago. 5 Replies

What's on your workbench?

Started by Paul Craig in Other stuff - off topic, fun stuff, whatever. Last reply by Cause the Blue rat 10 hours ago. 733 Replies

Oak Fret Board Finish?

Started by Frank Scott in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Blind Doughboy 23 hours ago. 19 Replies

VIDEO & PHOTOS: Naughty Cigar Box Guitar Has "Peep Show" Window!

Started by Shane Speal in Feature Articles. Last reply by Stuart Joseph yesterday. 1 Reply

Bedpan pickups

Started by Robert Bryan in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Paul Craig yesterday. 5 Replies

Blog Posts

CBG project

Posted by Philip Hopper on October 13, 2018 at 3:45pm 3 Comments


Posted by Freddie Cisneros on October 13, 2018 at 2:24pm 2 Comments

My Foray Into the World of CBGs

Posted by Poorness Studios on October 13, 2018 at 10:30am 2 Comments

interesting phone call

Posted by Thomas Blasque on October 13, 2018 at 9:22am 0 Comments

what a time it is

Posted by Thomas Blasque on October 13, 2018 at 9:07am 1 Comment

Latest Activity

cbgkent posted a discussion

One string ukulele (the "very diddly bow")

Here's my latest video on one of my latest guitars builds. Loads of fun to play with a little bit…See More
15 minutes ago
Frank Scott replied to Frank Scott's discussion String Gauges -3 string ?
"Hello John,  I would be tuning GDG (basic open G tuning). I would think the heavier gauge set…"
18 minutes ago
cbgkent posted a status
"Ever wondered what a "very diddly bow" sounds like"
19 minutes ago
Uncle John commented on BeetleJuice!'s photo

Workin' for a livin'

"That is a cool pic.  I know you make great sounding guitars and pickups.  What are those…"
1 hour ago
Uncle John commented on Muddy Creek Guitars's video

I play with Banjovi & Hawkins (and Anne).

"Pretty cool, John.  Love that song.  Good job, man!"
1 hour ago
Uncle John commented on Danny Gordon's video

Fire On The Mountain Marshall Tucker Band

"Great looking Hat, Danny.  Good job!"
1 hour ago
ChickenboneJohn replied to Frank Scott's discussion String Gauges -3 string ?
"What gauge you choose depends on what tuning you go can still put a lot of load on a neck…"
1 hour ago
Keith Rearick liked Brian Fink's video
1 hour ago
Keith Rearick liked Dave Lynas's video
1 hour ago
Don Stachovak replied to Frank Scott's discussion String Gauges -3 string ?
"I would try the .017 .026 .036 first. That's the middle 3 from a set of 10's and should…"
1 hour ago
Chris "Fingerz" Zaferes commented on Chris "Fingerz" Zaferes's photo

"Econo" Line MC-1

"Thank you, UJ!"
1 hour ago
Keith Rearick liked tontonsb's video
1 hour ago



© 2018   Created by Ben "C. B. Gitty" Baker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service