So, I recently bought some slightly blemished resonator cones from Charles Atchison during a one-time fire sale he posted on Facebook. The cones came and look fine to me (may be just scuffed slightly, or maybe not at deep as they should be). Regardless, I am totally good with my purchase. I think regardless of whatever is supposed to be wrong with them (again, I can't really tell, or know what to look for), I think they will sound great. So with these I now have a bunch of questions... 1. I see a lot of Resonator CBGs have 4-strings. I know there are "no rules", and have seen some 3-stringers, but are there any advantages to doing a 4-string that might outweigh doing a 3-string? Or does it now really matter, and up to the player? 2. I have seen what look like painted cones. If I wanted to paint the cone to match the box I am using... are there any disadvantages to doing this? 3. Is it a big deal to fret or not fret? I see a few fretless reso builds, but very few and wonder if there is a reason for it (like the 4 vs. 3 string question). 4. If I use a piezo disc pickup, do I mount it inside the cone (under the biscuit)? Or should I avoid piezo discs all together with a reso, and stick with a wound pup? Overall I am not overly concerned about the build (even though I really have 3 other build before I probably get to doing this one). I would just like to have a bit more info to try to understand and digest before I get started. As always, thanks for the feedback ya'll provide.
You need to be a member of Cigar Box Nation to add comments!
Replies
Thanks for all the comments and information. This should help me some. Some last questions... What do people use for a covers? ... like what are some cheap/found alternatives to buying an actual cover? Is the cover purely decorative, or do the cone covers serve a purpose?
Thanks again!
On a side note.. I think it was wayfinder that I saw having coloured blue cones buy blowtortching/heating them. I think this has to do with oxidised metals. But I don't think I would paint one. You could try sandpapering the surface and using a wood stain but it might not exactly be a uniform taint. Ask wayfinder about the heat thing.
Doing my first build. Using both a piezo on the underside of the cone under the biscuit and a magnetic neck pickup with a 3 way switch. Not sure if I'll install knobs or use a behringer external DI box. Have an acoustic one for my ukes so I don't have to install pre-amps in them. About $30
To fret or not to fret. When you finger a note with a fret it sustained for longer. This all adds to the resonator. If your playing mostly slide it's relatively the same as having a movable fret.
A pup will amplify the string vibration though it's magnetic field. So having a resonator amplified through a pup won't exactly pick up all those wonderful resonances.
3 or 4 string it's mostly a choice between playing style and frequency through the resonator. On a side note, a resonator is harder to build properly to resonate at lower frequencies. I think. I might be wrong here.
I might be wrong everywhere too. Just adding food for thought.
A lot of 4-string players tune GDGB so it actually makes the full chord (vs GDG), but it comes down to personal choice. Same with frets or not. Personally, if I were planning on playing slide primarily, I'd skip the frets, but that choice has to do mainly with my slide technique (or, more correctly, lack thereof).
As far as pickups go, I see a lot with mag pickups. Some with both mag and piezos. Depends on the sound you want. I've seen one with a small microphone mounted inside with the thinking that it wouldn't change the sound any, but just amplify it.
I like a 4 string because you can tune the high string to B which rings out real nice. Not a fan of piezo pups, especially if put under a metal object like hub cap or aluminum cone. I think painting the cone would dual the sound & output level. I have a tri-cone that came with the bridge painted. I removed the paint & it was mo' better. If your mainly playing slide fretless is sweet. All this IMHO.
I just built one using C.A.'s cones. It was my first build. I used 3 strings and I think it sounds real nice. I used a wound pup. I was on Youtube and watched some videos of Junksville Guitars. He builds some nice stuff and he did not recommend using a piezo. Mine sounds pretty good acoustically and even better when plugged in. I think paint will dull up your sound. Mine is a fully fretted git. I was pretty upset at first as I kept hitting the frets with the slide. That however was MY fault. I never played git before and after my first 2 weeks I have improved my playing skills enough that hitting the frets with the slide is no longer an issue hitting the right notes still is! (you have to keep it flat, not cock it) Hope this helps you make some decisions.
IMG_1784.JPG