I have been struggling to learn the CBG. Is the fretless slide, fretted fingering / finger picking or just strumming with chords the easiest way to learn. I am not making much progress with the slide. I have no previous music experience

You need to be a member of Cigar Box Nation to add comments!

Join Cigar Box Nation

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Anyone you pick up and play 20 minutes every other day. It's That Simple.

    Practice and practice smart  always add something each time. look on this site and youtube for lessons.

    ASK THIS GUY.

    306162842?profile=original

     

    • Now you know why the original working title to "Yesterday" was "Scrambled Eggs!"
  • I would say for most, a diatonic fretted 3 string tuned Gdg.  Strumming all & fretting only the thin string makes all the notes "good",   easy to sound out simple,  childhood & nice sounding improvised songs immediately & learn about intervals looking at the one string.   Like the didley bow in that respect, but a much fuller sound.  The challenge beginners will have with unfretted necks is getting a decent sound because of too many wrong places to put the slide.  I know that CBG have "no rules", but part of music is physics, which has definite rules.

    I have given several CBGs to friends and find the slide is too foreign for many beginners to find easy success with.

     

  • i  gotta  agree  with  the  fretless crowd  . 

    or a  d-bow as easiest  to  learn  .

    as for fretted      ,  a ducli   scale  is easiest  to  learn .   

  • I built a 3 string fretless slide cbg first. I'd never played slide guitar much at all. I messed around with that a while picking up things here n there from Shane Speal, Mike Snowden and Chickenbone John youtube videos. Then I built a one string diddley bow and actually learned more about handling the slide and picking out things by ear. Everyone learns differently. Above all ... Have Fun !!!

    • Which is why I said one string D-bow or canjo as the simplest.The only things you have to worry about are 1 string, and where to put the slide. In the Middle Ages, beginning in about the ninth century, Gregorian chant and mathematical musical relationships were taught to monks using a monochord: essentially a diddley bow, but with a sheep intestine string suspended between two wooden bridges, above a large (some of them were 8 ft long!) resonating box. It was played with either a wooden dowel, or a leg or jawbone, lightly riding on the string, just like a modern slide instrument. The notes were marked at specific places on the resonating box. There is a woman in the UK that builds modern replica models of these teaching devices:

      http://www.trombamarina.com/instruments/monochord

      Many of the early blues musicians reported learning the rudiments of music the same way; Elmore James and earlier blues greats reported stringing a piece of wire on the wall or corner of a shack, using one bottle as a bridge, and another as the slide, creating a gigantic diddley bow from their own houses!

      If it was good enough for ninth century monks and early twentieth century Mississippi slave descendants and sharecropping farmers to learn the rudiments of music, note intervals, pitch, etc., then it should be good enough for someone with "no previous music experience." Or, do like the kids in elementary schools where the music programs haven't suffered budget cuts, and get a cheap Yamaha recorder and a xylophone. Teach yourself notes and the intervals between them. Then apply that to a d-bow, strum stick or canjo. Try dulcimer tuning on a one-string canjo. Then add two more strings. Then go to frets. One of the things that causes people "with no previous music experience" not to stick with guitar is the complications of too many strings to think about, painfully developing calluses, getting finger pressure just right in the right spot behind frets, and learning to manipulate the fingers both individually, and in concert. This can blow people's minds. Which is precisely why the Loog 3-stringer was designed for kids. Start simple, learn the basics work up to complex. You can't get any simpler stringed instrument than a one stringer. Watch Jack White build an electrified diddley bow in about 3 minutes in the documentary, "It Might Get Loud:"

      http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=dZNk76_4lds&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3...

      Simple. You can make music with it. Leave off the pickup first.
  • 3 string open tuning. View lessons on YouTube and find some from someone who plays music you like. No sense trying to emulate a sound that doesn't turn you on.

    Just pick up and play. Eventually (soon) you may want feeds and it opens a whole new world of possibilities. And you can still play slide! I hardly ever play my fretless now.

    So now you've heard advice all different ways. Its up to you to find out what works FOR YOU cos our experiences and opinions don't mean chit to YOUR playing and enjoyment.
    • That should read frets, not feeds. Bad phone typing.
  • I purposely built my first few guitars without frets forcing me to concentrate on the slide. I rarely even pickup a fretted guitar anymore.

  • HI, do not try to learn diddley bow!...you have to be rather talented to make it sound good!...try a 3 string....a diddley bow you will need to a have a good ear for tone and pitch , otherwise you will get frustrated fast!!!

     

    a three string you can let the strings ring open and the instrument will sound good with little effort!

This reply was deleted.