I don't know guys, typically, I'd agree with you, glue and clamp, but, you'll be reapplying the pressure and it will want to pull apart again, the glued joint won't, but right next to it might pull apart since it's got grain working against it. I'd still just open up the slit and glue in a piece of flat material, leave it in it's relaxed position, or as suggested, a face plate, or plate on the back. I could be wrong, only an observation.
Your idea of opening the crack and filling it with a sliver of wood may put more stress on the wood around the hole and cause a new crack. Also, it may make the hole bigger causing a loose tuning key to rattle.
This is the reason my guitar has a "redesigned" headstock.
All the tuners used to be on one side. A crack started in the same place as the one shown above. The crack migrated to the other side of the hole. So I had to reshape the end of the headstock and move the other tuners to the the other side.
That's why the plate is a good idea, to keep the problem from reoccurring in that spot or another. The plate would absorb the stress and possibly help with tone and sustain.
I second the glue it and clamp it fix. I like Darryl's recommendation of adding the plate to either top or back since the grain is running the opposite way as Richard pointed out. That will reinforce the headstock against more splits later.
As it,s a cbg , maybe you could re inforce it with a bit of 1/8 aluminium plate like i did on the one pictured when i thought i,d got a bit thin on the headstock, so added it to be safe
looks like the grain was running the wrong direction on your wings for the headstock, this contributed to the split, you may get more, if it splits again, make a one piece face for the headstock and glue over the headstock, may need longer tuners or shave down the headstock afterwards.
but, try a simple repair first, may get many more years of enjoyment without all the extra work.
Is this an expensive instrument, collectable, or a CBG? Hate to give advice on something best left as is for value sake, but if something you want to use and have repaired, personally, since it's split all the way through, what I've done to similar repairs, is to open up the split with a saw blade/sandpaper and make an insert to slide into the opening made of the same material, glued in place, re-file/sand/drill as needed, using the same wood material will make the repair nearly invisible.
Other headstocks in worse condition I've made a laminate headstock top plate, like the way you can find a Mahogany neck/headstock with a Rosewood top plate...ie; Martin, etc
Replies
I don't know guys, typically, I'd agree with you, glue and clamp, but, you'll be reapplying the pressure and it will want to pull apart again, the glued joint won't, but right next to it might pull apart since it's got grain working against it. I'd still just open up the slit and glue in a piece of flat material, leave it in it's relaxed position, or as suggested, a face plate, or plate on the back. I could be wrong, only an observation.
Your idea of opening the crack and filling it with a sliver of wood may put more stress on the wood around the hole and cause a new crack. Also, it may make the hole bigger causing a loose tuning key to rattle.
This is the reason my guitar has a "redesigned" headstock.
All the tuners used to be on one side. A crack started in the same place as the one shown above. The crack migrated to the other side of the hole. So I had to reshape the end of the headstock and move the other tuners to the the other side.
That's why the plate is a good idea, to keep the problem from reoccurring in that spot or another. The plate would absorb the stress and possibly help with tone and sustain.
It's fix and add plate or time to strip off the wings and put new ones on with the grain in the right direction and possibly harder wood.
I second the glue it and clamp it fix. I like Darryl's recommendation of adding the plate to either top or back since the grain is running the opposite way as Richard pointed out. That will reinforce the headstock against more splits later.
As it,s a cbg , maybe you could re inforce it with a bit of 1/8 aluminium plate like i did on the one pictured when i thought i,d got a bit thin on the headstock, so added it to be safe
Ahhhh, this guy...
looks like the grain was running the wrong direction on your wings for the headstock, this contributed to the split, you may get more, if it splits again, make a one piece face for the headstock and glue over the headstock, may need longer tuners or shave down the headstock afterwards.
but, try a simple repair first, may get many more years of enjoyment without all the extra work.
Thanks for the reply
Is this an expensive instrument, collectable, or a CBG? Hate to give advice on something best left as is for value sake, but if something you want to use and have repaired, personally, since it's split all the way through, what I've done to similar repairs, is to open up the split with a saw blade/sandpaper and make an insert to slide into the opening made of the same material, glued in place, re-file/sand/drill as needed, using the same wood material will make the repair nearly invisible.
Other headstocks in worse condition I've made a laminate headstock top plate, like the way you can find a Mahogany neck/headstock with a Rosewood top plate...ie; Martin, etc
thanks for the reply , but its a rough and ready CBG, just want to keep it playing